| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu35 | WCSU ball on WCSU35. |
| | | WC wins toss and defers to 2nd half. Montclair rec. defends north |
| | | Hunter Leili kickoff 54 yards to the MSU11, Patt Caggiano return 24 yards to the MSU35 (Tyrell Ballard). |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu35 | Bill Roman rush for 6 yards to the MSU41 (Justin Rice). |
| Msu | 2-4 | at Msu41 | Bill Roman rush for loss of 6 yards to the MSU35 (Tyrell Ballard). |
| Msu | 3-10 | at Msu35 | Drew Cathey pass complete to Kevin Grady for 14 yards to the MSU49, 1ST DOWN MSU (Tom Lacey). |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu49 | Bill Roman rush for 10 yards to the WCSU41, 1ST DOWN MSU (Nick Tulloch). |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Wcsu41 | MSU ball on WCSU42. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Wcsu42 | 2nd and 1. |
| Msu | 2-1 | at Wcsu42 | Bill Roman rush for 5 yards to the WCSU37, 1ST DOWN MSU (Tom Lacey). |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Wcsu37 | Drew Cathey pass incomplete to Bryan Ogden. |
| Msu | 2-10 | at Wcsu37 | Drew Cathey pass complete to Bryan Ogden for 15 yards to the WCSU22, 1ST DOWN MSU (Corey Lawlor). |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Wcsu22 | Bill Roman rush for 1 yard to the WCSU21 (Michael Lacaria). |
| Msu | 2-9 | at Wcsu21 | Drew Cathey pass complete to Bill Roman for 2 yards to the WCSU19 (Maliik Tinney). |
| Msu | 3-7 | at Wcsu19 | Drew Cathey pass incomplete to Mark Reynolds. |
| Msu | 4-7 | at Wcsu19 | John Schubert field goal attempt from 36 BLOCKED, recovered by WCSU Bobby Durham at WCSU30 spot at WCSU30, clock 09:53 (blocked by Bobby Durham), Bobby Durham for no gain to the WCSU30. |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 47 yards, TOP 07:57 |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu30 | Will Arndt pass complete to David Plaza for 7 yards to the WCSU37 (Marc Aspinwall). |
| Wcsu | 2-3 | at Wcsu37 | Will Arndt pass complete to Octavias McKoy for 13 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN WCSU (Michael Klimek). |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu50 | Octavias McKoy rush for 6 yards to the MSU44 (Adnan Sakiri). |
| Wcsu | 2-4 | at Msu44 | Octavias McKoy rush for 2 yards to the MSU42 (Adnan Sakiri). |
| Wcsu | 3-2 | at Msu42 | Will Arndt sacked for loss of 4 yards to the MSU46 (Joe Koonce). |
| Wcsu | 4-6 | at Msu46 | R. Falaguerra punt 42 yards to the MSU4, out-of-bounds, PENALTY WCSU illegal block (Tyrell Ballard) 15 yards to the MSU19, 1st and 10, MSU ball on MSU19. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 24 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu19 | MONTCLAIR STATE drive start at 07:03. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu19 | Bill Roman rush for 6 yards to the MSU25 (Tom Lacey). |
| Msu | 2-4 | at Msu25 | Bill Roman rush for 21 yards to the MSU46, 1ST DOWN MSU (Tom Lacey). |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu46 | Bill Roman rush for 5 yards to the WCSU49 (Michael Lacaria). |
| Msu | 2-5 | at Wcsu49 | Drew Cathey pass complete to Bryan Ogden for 11 yards to the WCSU38, 1ST DOWN MSU. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Wcsu38 | Bill Roman rush for 2 yards to the WCSU36 (Michael Lacaria;Devin Myers). |
| Msu | 2-8 | at Wcsu36 | Bill Roman rush for loss of 5 yards to the WCSU41 (Mike Farnsworth). |
| Msu | 3-13 | at Wcsu41 | Drew Cathey pass complete to Bryan Ogden for 17 yards to the WCSU24, 1ST DOWN MSU (Michael Lacaria). |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Wcsu24 | Patt Caggiano rush for loss of 1 yard to the WCSU25 (Tyrell Ballard). |
| Msu | 2-11 | at Wcsu25 | Drew Cathey pass complete to Aaron Williams for 7 yards to the WCSU18 (Bill Birdsell). |
| Msu | 3-4 | at Wcsu18 | Bill Roman rush for 11 yards to the WCSU7, 1ST DOWN MSU (Bobby Durham). |
| Msu | 1-G | at Wcsu07 | Bill Roman rush for 3 yards to the WCSU4 (Tom Lacey;Justin Rice). |
| Msu | 2-G | at Wcsu04 | Patt Caggiano rush for 4 yards to the WCSU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:23. |
| | | John Schubert kick attempt good. |
| | | Montclair State 7, Western Connecticut 0 |
| | | Drive: 12 plays, 81 yards, TOP 06:40 |
| | | John Schubert kickoff 58 yards to the WCSU7, Pariss Woods return 28 yards to the WCSU35 (John Schubert). |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu35 | WESTERN CONNECTICUT drive start at 00:23. |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu35 | Will Arndt pass intercepted by Marc Aspinwall at the WCSU48, Garrett Rees return 0 yards to the WCSU48. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:14 |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Wcsu48 | MONTCLAIR STATE drive start at 00:09. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Wcsu48 | Bill Roman rush for 7 yards to the WCSU41 (Phil Santana). |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 7 yards, TOP 04:30 |
| | | Montclair State 7, Western Connecticut 0 |
| Msu | 2-3 | at Wcsu41 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Msu | 2-3 | at Wcsu41 | Bill Roman rush for 2 yards to the WCSU39 (Devin Myers). |
| Msu | 3-1 | at Wcsu39 | Bill Roman rush for 14 yards to the WCSU25, 1ST DOWN MSU (Phil Santana;Maliik Tinney). |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Wcsu25 | Patt Caggiano rush for 2 yards to the WCSU23 (Michael Lacaria). |
| Msu | 2-8 | at Wcsu23 | Drew Cathey pass complete to Kevin Grady for 10 yards to the WCSU13, 1ST DOWN MSU (Phil Santana). |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Wcsu13 | PENALTY MSU unsportsmanlike conduct 5 yards to the WCSU18. |
| Msu | 1-15 | at Wcsu18 | Patt Caggiano rush for 3 yards to the WCSU15 (Corey Lawlor;Devin Myers). |
| Msu | 2-12 | at Wcsu15 | Drew Cathey pass complete to Omar Morales for 3 yards to the WCSU12 (Bobby Durham). |
| Msu | 3-9 | at Wcsu12 | Patt Caggiano rush for 2 yards to the WCSU10 (Corey Lawlor). |
| Msu | 4-7 | at Wcsu10 | John Schubert field goal attempt from 28 MISSED - wide left, spot at WCSU20, clock 10:39. |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 38 yards, TOP 04:30 |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu20 | WESTERN CONNECTICUT drive start at 10:39. |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu20 | Octavias McKoy rush for 1 yard to the WCSU21 (Michael Klimek). |
| Wcsu | 2-9 | at Wcsu21 | Will Arndt pass incomplete to C. Falguerra (Michael Klimek). |
| Wcsu | 3-9 | at Wcsu21 | Will Arndt pass complete to David Plaza for 3 yards to the WCSU24 (Dan Barletta). |
| Wcsu | 4-6 | at Wcsu24 | R. Falaguerra punt 32 yards to the MSU44, Patt Caggiano return 2 yards to the MSU46 (Patrick Jordan). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 4 yards, TOP 01:29 |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu46 | MONTCLAIR STATE drive start at 09:10. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu46 | Bill Roman rush for no gain to the MSU46 (Devin Myers). |
| Msu | 2-10 | at Msu46 | Drew Cathey pass incomplete to Aaron Williams (Devin Myers). |
| Msu | 3-10 | at Msu46 | Drew Cathey pass complete to Ben Kohle for 26 yards to the WCSU28 (Corey Lawlor), PENALTY MSU pass interference (Ben Kohle) 15 yards to the MSU31, NO PLAY. |
| Msu | 3-25 | at Msu31 | Drew Cathey pass complete to Ben Kohle for 18 yards to the MSU49 (Phil Santana). |
| Msu | 4-7 | at Msu49 | Jermaine Terrel punt 37 yards to the WCSU14, C. Falguerra return 18 yards to the WCSU32. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 3 yards, TOP 02:04 |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu32 | WESTERN CONNECTICUT drive start at 07:06. |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu32 | Will Arndt pass complete to M. Highsmith for loss of 6 yards to the WCSU26 (Matt Trivigno). |
| Wcsu | 2-16 | at Wcsu26 | Will Arndt pass incomplete to S. DeJournett (C.J. Conway), PENALTY MSU offside defense (Rashad White) 5 yards to the WCSU31, NO PLAY. |
| Wcsu | 2-11 | at Wcsu31 | Will Arndt pass incomplete to C. Falguerra. |
| Wcsu | 3-11 | at Wcsu31 | Will Arndt pass incomplete to C. Falguerra. |
| Wcsu | 4-11 | at Wcsu31 | R. Falaguerra punt 55 yards to the MSU14, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 01:30 |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu14 | MONTCLAIR STATE drive start at 05:36. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu14 | Bill Roman rush for 4 yards to the MSU18 (Phil Santana;Bobby Durham). |
| Msu | 2-6 | at Msu18 | Bill Roman rush for 1 yard to the MSU19, fumble forced by Devin Myers, fumble by Bill Roman recovered by WCSU Mike Farnsworth at MSU19, Mike Farnsworth for 19 yards to the MSU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 04:45. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 5 yards, TOP 00:51 |
| | | Hunter Leili kick attempt good. |
| | | Montclair State 7, Western Connecticut 7 |
| | | Hunter Leili kickoff 43 yards to the MSU22, fair catch by Michael Klimek. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu25 | MONTCLAIR STATE drive start at 04:45. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu25 | Bill Roman rush for 7 yards to the MSU32 (Tyrell Ballard). |
| Msu | 2-3 | at Msu32 | Bill Roman rush for 2 yards to the MSU34 (Michael Lacaria), PENALTY MSU holding 10 yards to the MSU22, NO PLAY. |
| Msu | 2-13 | at Msu22 | Timeout Montclair State, clock 04:00. |
| Msu | 2-13 | at Msu22 | Drew Cathey pass complete to Bryan Ogden for 9 yards to the MSU31, PENALTY MSU holding (Ch. Avedissian) 10 yards to the MSU12, NO PLAY. |
| Msu | 2-23 | at Msu12 | Bill Roman rush for 21 yards to the MSU33 (Maliik Tinney). |
| Msu | 3-2 | at Msu33 | Drew Cathey pass complete to Kevin Grady for 5 yards to the MSU38, 1ST DOWN MSU (Kenneth Bradley). |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu38 | Drew Cathey pass complete to Aaron Williams for 6 yards to the MSU44 (Dan Allen;Maliik Tinney). |
| Msu | 2-4 | at Msu44 | Drew Cathey pass complete to Bryan Ogden for 9 yards to the WCSU47, 1ST DOWN MSU (Kenneth Bradley). |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Wcsu47 | Drew Cathey sacked for loss of 9 yards to the MSU44 (Devin Myers), PENALTY MSU holding declined. |
| Msu | 2-19 | at Msu44 | Drew Cathey pass complete to Bryan Ogden for 11 yards to the WCSU45 (;Tyrell Ballard). |
| Msu | 3-8 | at Wcsu45 | Drew Cathey pass incomplete. |
| Msu | 4-8 | at Wcsu45 | Drew Cathey rush for 7 yards to the WCSU38. |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 37 yards, TOP 03:58 |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu38 | Samod Cooley pass complete to Patrick Jordan for loss of 2 yards to the WCSU36 (Dan Valles). |
| Wcsu | 2-12 | at Wcsu36 | Jason Joseph rush for no gain to the WCSU36 (Dan Valles). |
| Wcsu | 3-12 | at Wcsu36 | WESTERN CONNECTICUT drive start at 00:47. |
| Wcsu | 3-12 | at Wcsu36 | Will Arndt pass incomplete to S. DeJournett. |
| Wcsu | 4-12 | at Wcsu36 | Will Arndt pass intercepted by Matt Mancino at the MSU31, Matt Mancino return 0 yards to the MSU31. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, minus 2 yards, TOP 00:12 |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu31 | MONTCLAIR STATE drive start at 00:35. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu31 | Drew Cathey pass incomplete. |
| Msu | 2-10 | at Msu31 | Drew Cathey pass incomplete to Mark Reynolds (Bobby Durham), PENALTY WCSU personal foul (Devin Myers) 15 yards to the MSU46, 1ST DOWN MSU, NO PLAY. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu46 | Drew Cathey pass intercepted by Maliik Tinney at the WCSU36, Maliik Tinney return 0 yards to the WCSU36. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 15 yards, TOP 00:19 |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu36 | WESTERN CONNECTICUT drive start at 00:16. |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu36 | Will Arndt pass complete to S. DeJournett for 24 yards to the MSU40, 1ST DOWN WCSU. |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Msu40 | Will Arndt pass incomplete to S. DeJournett (C.J. Conway). |
| Wcsu | 2-10 | at Msu40 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 24 yards, TOP 00:16 |
| | | Montclair State 7, Western Connecticut 7 |
| Wcsu | 2-10 | at Msu40 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, MSU ball on MSU35. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 24 yards, TOP 00:16 |
| | | John Schubert kickoff 56 yards to the WCSU9, Pariss Woods return 31 yards to the WCSU40 (Tariq Turner;Bill Shimko). |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu40 | WESTERN CONNECTICUT drive start at 15:00. |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu40 | Octavias McKoy rush for 3 yards to the WCSU43 (Marc Aspinwall). |
| Wcsu | 2-7 | at Wcsu43 | Octavias McKoy rush for 1 yard to the WCSU44 (Rashad White). |
| Wcsu | 3-6 | at Wcsu44 | Will Arndt pass complete to M. Highsmith for 20 yards to the MSU36, 1ST DOWN WCSU (Rashad White). |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Msu36 | PENALTY MSU personal foul (Rashad White) 15 yards to the MSU21, 1ST DOWN WCSU. |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Msu21 | Will Arndt pass complete to Octavias McKoy for 3 yards to the MSU18 (Bill Shimko;Joe Koonce). |
| Wcsu | 2-7 | at Msu18 | Will Arndt pass complete to Octavias McKoy for no gain to the MSU18 (Bill Shimko;Joe Koonce). |
| Wcsu | 3-7 | at Msu18 | Will Arndt pass complete to David Plaza for 2 yards to the MSU16 (Adnan Sakiri), PENALTY WCSU holding (Alan Quintero) 10 yards to the MSU28, NO PLAY. |
| Wcsu | 3-17 | at Msu28 | PENALTY WCSU false start (Connor Capasso) 5 yards to the MSU33. |
| Wcsu | 3-22 | at Msu33 | PENALTY MSU unsportsmanlike conduct (Rashad White) 15 yards to the MSU18, 1ST DOWN WCSU. |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Msu18 | Will Arndt rush for 2 yards to the MSU16 (Adnan Sakiri;Michael Klimek). |
| Wcsu | 2-8 | at Msu16 | Will Arndt pass complete to M. Highsmith for 16 yards to the MSU0, 1ST DOWN WCSU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:36. |
| | | Hunter Leili kick attempt good. |
| | | Western Connecticut 14, Montclair State 7 |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 60 yards, TOP 04:24 |
| | | Hunter Leili kickoff 43 yards to the MSU22, Rashad White return 11 yards to the MSU33 (Chris Davis). |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu33 | MONTCLAIR STATE drive start at 10:36. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu33 | Bill Roman rush for 8 yards to the MSU41 (Phil Santana;Devin Myers). |
| Msu | 2-2 | at Msu41 | Drew Cathey pass incomplete to Scott Smith (Tyrell Ballard). |
| Msu | 3-2 | at Msu41 | Bill Roman rush for 5 yards to the MSU46, 1ST DOWN MSU (Nick Tulloch), PENALTY WCSU personal foul (Nick Tulloch) 15 yards to the WCSU39, 1ST DOWN MSU. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Wcsu39 | 1st and 10. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Wcsu39 | Bill Roman rush for 3 yards to the WCSU36 (Michael Lacaria). |
| Msu | 2-7 | at Wcsu36 | Drew Cathey pass incomplete to Bryan Ogden (Matthew Datin). |
| Msu | 3-7 | at Wcsu36 | Drew Cathey pass incomplete to Mark Reynolds, PENALTY WCSU pass interference (Bobby Durham) 11 yards to the WCSU25, 1ST DOWN MSU, NO PLAY. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Wcsu25 | Bill Roman rush for no gain to the WCSU25 (Devin Myers). |
| Msu | 2-10 | at Wcsu25 | Drew Cathey pass incomplete to Omar Morales (Tom Lacey). |
| Msu | 3-10 | at Wcsu25 | Drew Cathey pass intercepted by Phil Santana at the WCSU13, Phil Santana return 0 yards to the WCSU13. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 42 yards, TOP 02:51 |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu13 | WESTERN CONNECTICUT drive start at 07:45. |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu13 | Octavias McKoy rush for 3 yards to the WCSU16 (Marc Aspinwall). |
| Wcsu | 2-7 | at Wcsu16 | Will Arndt pass complete to Octavias McKoy for 6 yards to the WCSU22 (C.J. Conway). |
| Wcsu | 3-1 | at Wcsu22 | Will Arndt sacked for loss of 3 yards to the WCSU19 (Kevin Barnes). |
| Wcsu | 4-4 | at Wcsu19 | R. Falaguerra punt 51 yards to the MSU30, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 02:05 |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu30 | MONTCLAIR STATE drive start at 05:40. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu30 | Bill Roman rush for 7 yards to the MSU37 (Tom Lacey;Phil Santana). |
| Msu | 2-3 | at Msu37 | Drew Cathey pass incomplete to Kevin Grady (Matthew Datin). |
| Msu | 3-3 | at Msu37 | Drew Cathey pass incomplete to Aaron Williams (Tom Lacey). |
| Msu | 4-3 | at Msu37 | Tariq Turner punt 52 yards to the WCSU11, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 7 yards, TOP 01:04 |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu11 | WESTERN CONNECTICUT drive start at 04:36. |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu11 | Octavias McKoy rush for 4 yards to the WCSU15 (Dan Avento). |
| Wcsu | 2-6 | at Wcsu15 | Octavias McKoy rush for 2 yards to the WCSU17 (S. Spiliotopoul;Adnan Sakiri). |
| Wcsu | 3-4 | at Wcsu17 | Octavias McKoy rush for loss of 1 yard to the WCSU16 (Dan Avento). |
| Wcsu | 4-5 | at Wcsu16 | R. Falaguerra punt 46 yards to the MSU38, Patt Caggiano return 22 yards to the WCSU40 (T. Champlain). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 5 yards, TOP 02:01 |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Wcsu40 | MONTCLAIR STATE drive start at 02:35. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Wcsu40 | Bill Roman rush for 3 yards to the WCSU37 (Michael Lacaria). |
| Msu | 2-7 | at Wcsu37 | Drew Cathey sacked for loss of 6 yards to the WCSU43 (Devin Myers). |
| Msu | 3-13 | at Wcsu43 | Drew Cathey sacked for loss of 7 yards to the 50 yardline (Mike Farnsworth). |
| Msu | 4-20 | at Msu50 | Steve Hellings punt 21 yards to the WCSU29, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 10 yards, TOP 02:06 |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu29 | WESTERN CONNECTICUT drive start at 00:29. |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu29 | Will Arndt pass complete to C. Falguerra for 8 yards to the WCSU37 (Rashad White). |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 8 yards, TOP 02:43 |
| | | Western Connecticut 14, Montclair State 7 |
| Wcsu | 2-2 | at Wcsu37 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Wcsu | 2-2 | at Wcsu37 | Will Arndt pass complete to Octavias McKoy for 16 yards to the MSU47, 1ST DOWN WCSU (Rashad White). |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Msu47 | Octavias McKoy rush for 3 yards to the MSU44 (Adnan Sakiri). |
| Wcsu | 2-7 | at Msu44 | Will Arndt sacked for loss of 6 yards to the 50 yardline (Josh Brown;Matt Trivigno). |
| Wcsu | 3-13 | at Wcsu50 | Will Arndt pass complete to S. DeJournett for 7 yards to the MSU43 (C.J. Conway). |
| Wcsu | 4-6 | at Msu43 | R. Falaguerra punt 25 yards to the MSU18, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 28 yards, TOP 02:43 |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu18 | MONTCLAIR STATE drive start at 12:46. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu18 | Bill Roman rush for loss of 4 yards to the MSU14 (Mike Farnsworth). |
| Msu | 2-14 | at Msu14 | Bill Roman rush for 2 yards to the MSU16 (Michael Lacaria;Phil Santana). |
| Msu | 3-12 | at Msu16 | Drew Cathey pass complete to Bryan Ogden for 11 yards to the MSU27 (Tyrell Ballard). |
| Msu | 4-1 | at Msu27 | Tariq Turner punt 41 yards to the WCSU32, C. Falguerra return 6 yards to the WCSU38 (Michael Bizzaro), PENALTY WCSU illegal block (Ryan Curtis) 10 yards to the WCSU28, 1st and 10, WCSU ball on WCSU28. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 9 yards, TOP 02:02 |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu28 | WESTERN CONNECTICUT drive start at 10:44. |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu28 | Octavias McKoy rush for 18 yards to the WCSU46, fumble forced by Joe Koonce, fumble by Octavias McKoy recovered by MSU Bill Shimko at WCSU46. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 18 yards, TOP 00:10 |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Wcsu46 | MONTCLAIR STATE drive start at 10:34. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Wcsu46 | Drew Cathey pass incomplete to Bryan Ogden, PENALTY WCSU pass interference (Corey Lawlor) 6 yards to the WCSU40, 1ST DOWN MSU, NO PLAY. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Wcsu40 | Drew Cathey sacked for loss of 11 yards to the MSU49 (Mike Farnsworth). |
| Msu | 2-21 | at Msu49 | Bill Roman rush for 2 yards to the WCSU49 (Mike Farnsworth). |
| Msu | 3-19 | at Wcsu49 | Drew Cathey pass complete to Ben Kohle for 21 yards to the WCSU28, 1ST DOWN MSU (Phil Santana). |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Wcsu28 | Bill Roman rush for 11 yards to the WCSU17, 1ST DOWN MSU (Corey Lawlor). |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Wcsu17 | Bill Roman rush for 1 yard to the WCSU16 (Nick Tulloch;Michael Lacaria). |
| Msu | 2-9 | at Wcsu16 | Drew Cathey pass complete to Aaron Williams for 11 yards to the WCSU5, 1ST DOWN MSU (Phil Santana). |
| Msu | 1-G | at Wcsu05 | Bill Roman rush for 5 yards to the WCSU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:49. |
| | | John Schubert kick attempt good. |
| | | Montclair State 14, Western Connecticut 14 |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 46 yards, TOP 03:45 |
| | | John Schubert kickoff 58 yards to the WCSU7, Bobby Durham return 23 yards to the WCSU30 (Nick Mangum;Dan Valles). |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu30 | WESTERN CONNECTICUT drive start at 06:49. |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu30 | Will Arndt pass incomplete to M. Highsmith. |
| Wcsu | 2-10 | at Wcsu30 | Will Arndt rush for 16 yards to the WCSU46, 1ST DOWN WCSU (Rashad White). |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu46 | PENALTY WCSU personal foul (David Plaza) 15 yards to the WCSU31. |
| Wcsu | 1-25 | at Wcsu31 | 2nd and 9. |
| Wcsu | 2-9 | at Wcsu31 | Octavias McKoy rush for 2 yards to the WCSU33 (Josh Brown). |
| Wcsu | 3-7 | at Wcsu33 | Will Arndt pass incomplete to M. Highsmith. |
| Wcsu | 4-7 | at Wcsu33 | R. Falaguerra punt 31 yards to the MSU36, Bryan Ogden return 4 yards to the MSU40. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 3 yards, TOP 01:43 |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu40 | MONTCLAIR STATE drive start at 05:06. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu40 | Bill Roman rush for no gain to the MSU40 (Tyrell Ballard). |
| Msu | 2-10 | at Msu40 | Drew Cathey pass intercepted by Corey Lawlor at the WCSU43, Corey Lawlor return 0 yards to the WCSU43. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:32 |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu43 | WESTERN CONNECTICUT drive start at 04:34. |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu43 | Octavias McKoy rush for 20 yards to the MSU37 (Adnan Sakiri), PENALTY WCSU holding (Alan Quintero) 4 yards to the WCSU47, NO PLAY. |
| Wcsu | 1-14 | at Wcsu47 | Will Arndt pass complete to C. Falguerra for 5 yards to the MSU48 (Rashad White). |
| Wcsu | 2-9 | at Msu48 | 2nd and 15. |
| Wcsu | 2-15 | at Msu48 | Will Arndt pass complete to M. Highsmith for 3 yards to the MSU45. |
| Wcsu | 3-12 | at Msu45 | Will Arndt pass complete to Maleek Riley for loss of 1 yard to the MSU46 (Adnan Sakiri), PENALTY WCSU illegal touching (Maleek Riley) 4 yards to the 50 yardline. |
| Wcsu | 3-17 | at Wcsu50 | 4th and 17. |
| Wcsu | 4-17 | at Wcsu50 | R. Falaguerra punt 37 yards to the MSU13, Patt Caggiano return 4 yards to the MSU17 (Tyrell Ballard). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 01:46 |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu17 | MONTCLAIR STATE drive start at 02:48. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu17 | Bill Roman rush for 3 yards to the MSU20 (Tom Lacey). |
| Msu | 2-7 | at Msu20 | Bill Roman rush for loss of 5 yards to the MSU15 (Phil Santana). |
| Msu | 3-12 | at Msu15 | Timeout Western Connecticut, clock 02:12. |
| Msu | 3-12 | at Msu15 | Bill Roman rush for 8 yards to the MSU23 (Michael Lacaria). |
| Msu | 4-4 | at Msu23 | Timeout Western Connecticut, clock 02:03. |
| Msu | 4-4 | at Msu23 | Tariq Turner punt 44 yards to the WCSU33, C. Falguerra return 17 yards to the 50 yardline (Josh McWilliams). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 00:54 |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu50 | WESTERN CONNECTICUT drive start at 01:54. |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Wcsu50 | Will Arndt pass complete to M. Highsmith for 25 yards to the MSU25, 1ST DOWN WCSU, PENALTY MSU holding declined. |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Msu25 | Octavias McKoy rush for 3 yards to the MSU22 (Rob Allen;Chris Petrucell). |
| Wcsu | 2-7 | at Msu22 | Octavias McKoy rush for 3 yards to the MSU19 (Rob Allen;Bill Shimko). |
| Wcsu | 3-4 | at Msu19 | Timeout Montclair State, clock 01:00. |
| Wcsu | 3-4 | at Msu19 | Octavias McKoy rush for 6 yards to the MSU13, 1ST DOWN WCSU (Adnan Sakiri). |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Msu13 | Octavias McKoy rush for 2 yards to the MSU11 (Rob Allen;Dan Valles). |
| Wcsu | 2-8 | at Msu11 | Timeout Montclair State, clock 00:30. |
| Wcsu | 2-8 | at Msu11 | Octavias McKoy rush for 1 yard to the MSU10, PENALTY WCSU holding (Johnnie Medina) 10 yards to the MSU20. |
| Wcsu | 2-17 | at Msu20 | 2nd and 17. |
| Wcsu | 2-17 | at Msu20 | Octavias McKoy rush for 3 yards to the MSU17 (Dan Avento), PENALTY MSU personal foul 9 yards to the MSU8, 1ST DOWN WCSU. |
| Wcsu | 1-G | at Msu08 | 1st and 8. |
| Wcsu | 1-G | at Msu08 | Timeout Western Connecticut, clock 00:04. |
| Wcsu | 1-G | at Msu08 | Timeout Montclair State, clock 00:04. |
| Wcsu | 1-G | at Msu08 | Hunter Leili field goal attempt from 26 MISSED - wide right, spot at MSU8, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 42 yards, TOP 01:54 |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu08 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Montclair State 14, Western Connecticut 14 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 25 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| | | Western Connecticut 20, Montclair State 14 |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu08 | Start of OT quarter, clock 15:00. |
| | | WCSU wins toss and will play defense and defend north goal. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu08 | Clock 15:00. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu08 | MSU ball on MSU25. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Msu25 | MSU ball on WCSU25. |
| Msu | 1-10 | at Wcsu25 | Bill Roman rush for loss of 7 yards to the WCSU32 (Tyrell Ballard). |
| Msu | 2-17 | at Wcsu32 | Drew Cathey pass complete to Aaron Williams for 5 yards to the WCSU27 (Matthew Datin). |
| Msu | 3-12 | at Wcsu27 | Drew Cathey pass incomplete to Aaron Williams. |
| Msu | 4-12 | at Wcsu27 | John Schubert field goal attempt from 44 MISSED - wide left, spot at MSU25, clock 15:00. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Msu25 | WESTERN CONNECTICUT drive start at 15:00. |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Msu25 | Change of possession, WCSU ball on MSU25, 1st and 10. |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Msu25 | WESTERN CONNECTICUT drive start at 15:00. |
| Wcsu | 1-10 | at Msu25 | Octavias McKoy rush for no gain to the MSU25 (Adnan Sakiri). |
| Wcsu | 2-10 | at Msu25 | Will Arndt pass complete to M. Highsmith for 24 yards to the MSU1, 1ST DOWN WCSU. |
| Wcsu | 1-G | at Msu01 | Octavias McKoy rush for 1 yard to the MSU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 15:00. |
| | | Western Connecticut 20, Montclair State 14 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 25 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| | | Western Connecticut 20, Montclair State 14 |